The Naksa and Its Impact on the Current Palestinian Situation

 The Naksa and Its Impact on the Current Palestinian Situation

Introduction

The term "Naksa," which translates to "setback" or "defeat" in Arabic, refers to the dramatic events of the 1967 Six-Day War that forever altered the course of Palestinian history. While the Nakba of 1948 represents the mass displacement and dispossession of Palestinian Arabs during the creation of the State of Israel, the Naksa of 1967 marked another critical juncture. During the Six-Day War, Israel captured the West Bank, Gaza Strip, East Jerusalem, and other territories, creating new realities that continue to shape the Palestinian experience. The Naksa not only resulted in further territorial losses but also deepened the political, economic, and social challenges faced by Palestinians to this day.

This article provides an in-depth examination of the Naksa and its far-reaching impact on the current Palestinian situation. We will explore the historical background leading up to the events of 1967, the immediate consequences of the war, and the long-term effects on Palestinian society. In doing so, we will discuss how the Naksa has influenced Palestinian national identity, political movements, economic conditions, and cultural memory. Furthermore, we will analyze the ongoing challenges of occupation, settlement expansion, and restrictions on civil liberties, as well as the international responses to the Palestinian plight. By understanding the Naksa and its enduring legacy, we can gain insight into the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the continued struggle for justice and self-determination.

1. Historical Background: Prelude to the Naksa

1.1 The Palestinian Situation Before 1967

Before the events of 1967, Palestine had already experienced significant upheaval and transformation. The establishment of Israel in 1948—the Nakba—led to the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians, the destruction of villages, and a profound alteration of the demographic landscape. Although the 1948 war left deep scars, the period following the Nakba was marked by a precarious status quo. The remaining Palestinians in the West Bank, Gaza Strip, and East Jerusalem faced military occupation, political marginalization, and severe economic challenges.

During the 1950s and early 1960s, the Palestinian people were forced to navigate life under martial law and a complex network of restrictions imposed by neighboring Arab states and, later, by the expanding Israeli state. Palestinian society was characterized by a sense of loss and longing, a collective memory of displacement that shaped national identity. In this context, the region experienced simmering tensions, with refugees and those still living in Palestine dreaming of a return to their ancestral lands while contending with an uncertain future.

1.2 The Emergence of the 1967 Conflict

The geopolitical landscape of the Middle East was volatile during the 1960s. Tensions between Israel and its Arab neighbors—Egypt, Jordan, Syria, and others—had been escalating over issues such as border disputes, arms buildups, and ideological differences. By the mid-1960s, a series of military skirmishes and provocative actions had heightened the risk of full-scale conflict.

The political climate was further complicated by shifting alliances and regional power dynamics. Arab nationalism, spearheaded by figures such as Egypt's Gamal Abdel Nasser, emphasized the need for Arab unity against perceived Western imperialism and Israeli expansion. Meanwhile, Israel, determined to secure its borders and assert its military strength, maintained a posture of vigilance and readiness for conflict.

In this charged atmosphere, the stage was set for a war that would redefine the map of the Middle East. The culmination of these tensions came in June 1967, when Israel launched a preemptive strike against its neighboring Arab states, leading to the outbreak of the Six-Day War.

2. The Naksa: The 1967 Six-Day War

2.1 Events of the Six-Day War

The Six-Day War, fought from June 5 to June 10, 1967, was a rapid and decisive conflict that resulted in dramatic territorial gains for Israel. In the span of six days, Israel defeated the combined forces of Egypt, Jordan, and Syria. The war was characterized by lightning-fast military operations, with air and ground forces achieving overwhelming victories.

Key events during the war included:

Preemptive Air Strikes: On the morning of June 5, Israel launched preemptive air strikes that decimated the Egyptian Air Force, effectively establishing air superiority.

Ground Invasions: Following the air strikes, Israeli ground forces swiftly advanced into the Sinai Peninsula, the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Golan Heights.

Rapid Territorial Gains: By the end of the war, Israel had occupied the entire Sinai Peninsula (later returned to Egypt following the Camp David Accords), the Gaza Strip, the West Bank (including East Jerusalem), and the Golan Heights.

Decisive Battles: Numerous engagements during the war, such as the battle for Jerusalem’s Old City and the fighting on the Golan Heights, underscored the speed and ferocity of the Israeli military campaign.

2.2 Territorial Changes and Occupation

The immediate result of the Six-Day War was a dramatic redrawing of the map. The territories captured by Israel included:

The West Bank: Home to millions of Palestinians, including East Jerusalem, which holds immense religious and historical significance.

The Gaza Strip: A densely populated coastal area that had already been experiencing economic hardship.

East Jerusalem: Long considered the spiritual heart of the Palestinian people, it became part of the occupied territory.

The Golan Heights: A strategically important plateau that has remained under Israeli control since the war.

The Sinai Peninsula: Although later returned to Egypt, its capture demonstrated the shifting balance of power in the region.

The occupation of these territories marked the beginning of a new era in Palestinian history. The annexation of East Jerusalem and the settlement of the West Bank introduced unprecedented challenges to Palestinian society, setting in motion a cycle of resistance, repression, and international diplomacy that continues to this day.

3. The Immediate Aftermath of the Naksa

3.1 The Human Cost of War

The Six-Day War, while brief, inflicted a heavy toll on both military personnel and civilians. Although the casualty figures varied by account, the loss of life was significant on all sides. For Palestinians, the war resulted in:

Increased Displacement: In addition to the mass displacement that occurred during the Nakba, the 1967 war forced thousands more Palestinians to flee their homes.

Widespread Trauma: The speed and brutality of the conflict left deep psychological scars. Families witnessed the destruction of homes, the loss of loved ones, and the sudden imposition of military rule.

Economic Disruption: The war shattered local economies, disrupted trade, and undermined agricultural production, exacerbating poverty and economic instability in the occupied territories.

3.2 The Onset of Military Occupation

Following the war, the Israeli military quickly established control over the newly captured territories. The occupation introduced a host of restrictive measures that fundamentally altered the lives of Palestinians:

Military Law: In the West Bank and Gaza, Palestinians were placed under military law, subjecting them to curfews, checkpoints, and arbitrary arrests.

Settler Expansion: Israeli settlements began to proliferate in the occupied territories, encroaching on Palestinian land and resources.

Restrictions on Movement: The establishment of roadblocks, the construction of the separation barrier, and the imposition of travel permits further isolated Palestinian communities.

Control of Resources: Israeli authorities gained control over critical resources such as water and land, undermining the economic viability of Palestinian agriculture and industry.

4. The Long-Term Impact on Palestinian Society

4.1 Shaping Palestinian National Identity

The Naksa has become a defining moment in Palestinian collective memory, profoundly shaping national identity and political consciousness. The loss of territory and the imposition of occupation have instilled a persistent sense of injustice and resistance among Palestinians. Key aspects include:

A Narrative of Dispossession: The 1967 defeat reinforced the narrative of displacement that began with the Nakba, leading to a sense of cumulative loss that spans generations.

Symbolism in Resistance: The Naksa has been memorialized in art, literature, and political discourse, serving as a rallying cry for those advocating for Palestinian rights and the right of return.

The Emergence of New Political Movements: The occupation catalyzed the rise of various Palestinian political movements. Groups like Fatah, Hamas, and others emerged partly in response to the ongoing oppression following the Naksa, each offering different visions for resistance and statehood.

4.2 The Evolution of Palestinian Politics

The political landscape among Palestinians has been irrevocably altered by the Naksa. The consequences include:

Fragmentation and Factionalism: The occupation and its associated hardships have contributed to internal divisions among Palestinians, often leading to rivalries between factions such as Fatah and Hamas. These divisions have complicated efforts to present a unified political front.

Radicalization and Militancy: In response to prolonged occupation and systemic injustice, some segments of Palestinian society have turned to militancy as a form of resistance. The cycle of violence has, in turn, impacted the prospects for peace negotiations.

Diplomatic Engagement: The Naksa spurred Palestinians to seek international recognition and support. The establishment of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and subsequent diplomatic efforts are direct outcomes of the struggle initiated by the Naksa.

4.3 Economic Consequences and Dependency

The territorial losses and subsequent occupation have had long-lasting effects on the Palestinian economy:

Agricultural Decline: The confiscation of fertile lands and water resources has severely impacted Palestinian agriculture, a traditional backbone of the economy.

High Unemployment and Poverty: Economic stagnation in the occupied territories has led to high unemployment rates, especially among the youth, exacerbating social instability.

Dependency on Aid: The economic challenges have forced many Palestinians to rely on international humanitarian aid, which, while essential, often comes with conditions that limit economic independence.

4.4 Social Fabric and Community Life

The Naksa disrupted the traditional social fabric of Palestinian communities:

Disruption of Family and Community Ties: Forced displacement and the physical barriers imposed by occupation have fractured close-knit communities, leading to isolation and social fragmentation.

Psychological Impact: The collective trauma experienced by generations of Palestinians under occupation has led to widespread mental health issues, including anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

Cultural Resilience: Despite these challenges, Palestinian communities have demonstrated remarkable cultural resilience. Oral histories, art, and music serve as vital tools for preserving memory and fostering a sense of unity in the face of adversity.

5. The Naksa and the International Peace Process

5.1 Negotiations and the Oslo Accords

The Naksa has been a central issue in international attempts to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The Oslo Accords, signed in the 1990s, were a significant milestone aimed at achieving a two-state solution. However, the legacy of the Naksa continued to influence negotiations:

Unresolved Territorial Disputes: The occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem, direct consequences of the Naksa, remains one of the most contentious issues in peace talks.

The Right of Return: Palestinians demand recognition of the right of return for refugees displaced by both the Nakba and the Naksa—a demand that Israel has consistently rejected.

Security Concerns: Israel’s emphasis on security has often overshadowed Palestinian calls for justice and self-determination, leading to a stalemate in negotiations.

5.2 International Mediators and Their Role

International actors, including the United Nations, the United States, the European Union, and various non-governmental organizations, have attempted to mediate the conflict. Their efforts have included:

Diplomatic Initiatives: Various peace proposals have sought to address the consequences of the Naksa, though none have yet led to a lasting resolution.

Human Rights Advocacy: International organizations have consistently condemned human rights violations associated with the occupation, calling for adherence to international law.

Economic and Humanitarian Aid: Aid programs funded by international bodies aim to alleviate the economic hardships imposed by the occupation, though they often fail to address the root causes of the conflict.

5.3 The Role of Global Public Opinion

Global public opinion has increasingly played a role in shaping the discourse around the Naksa and the broader Palestinian struggle:

Social Media and Digital Activism: Platforms like Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram have amplified Palestinian voices and provided real-time documentation of occupation-related abuses.

International Protests and Demonstrations: Pro-Palestinian demonstrations around the world highlight the global solidarity with Palestinians, urging governments to take action against injustices.

Academic and Cultural Discourse: Universities and cultural institutions have hosted conferences, film festivals, and art exhibitions that critically examine the legacy of the Naksa and its impact on Palestinian society.

6. The Cultural Memory of the Naksa

6.1 Artistic Expression and Resistance

Art has long been a powerful medium through which Palestinians have expressed their collective trauma and resistance to the Naksa. Visual artists, poets, musicians, and filmmakers use their craft to capture the human cost of occupation and to assert a resilient Palestinian identity:

Poetry and Literature: Poets like Mahmoud Darwish have immortalized the pain of displacement and the longing for return through evocative verses and narratives. Their work serves as a cultural repository of memory and resistance.

Visual Arts: Murals, paintings, and sculptures depicting scenes of loss, struggle, and hope are common in Palestinian communities. These artworks serve not only as memorials to the Naksa but also as active symbols of resistance against erasure.

Film and Theater: Documentaries and dramatic works focus on personal testimonies and historical accounts of the Naksa, offering audiences an intimate look into the lived realities of those affected by the conflict.

6.2 Annual Commemorations and Naksa Day

Every year, Palestinians and their supporters commemorate Naksa Day on June 5—the anniversary of the 1967 war. These commemorations include:

Public Demonstrations: Mass protests and rallies are organized in Palestinian communities worldwide to honor the memory of the Naksa and demand justice.

Cultural Events: Poetry readings, musical performances, and art exhibitions are held to celebrate Palestinian heritage and ensure that the narratives of displacement are passed on to future generations.

Educational Initiatives: Workshops, seminars, and school programs are dedicated to educating younger generations about the historical significance of the Naksa, ensuring that its legacy remains a living part of Palestinian identity.

6.3 The Role of Oral History

Oral history is a crucial aspect of how Palestinians remember the Naksa. Through storytelling, interviews, and community gatherings, firsthand accounts of the Naksa are preserved:

Family Narratives: Many Palestinian families have preserved the memory of their displacement through personal stories, ensuring that the trauma and resilience of their ancestors are never forgotten.

Community Archives: Local organizations have established oral history projects to document the experiences of survivors and their descendants, creating invaluable resources for historical research and cultural preservation.

7. The Impact of the Naksa on the Current Palestinian Situation

7.1 Demographic Changes and the Refugee Crisis

The Naksa exacerbated an already critical refugee crisis that began with the Nakba. The events of 1967 led to further displacement of Palestinians, contributing to a protracted refugee problem:

Increased Refugee Populations: Millions of Palestinians remain displaced, living in refugee camps in neighboring countries such as Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria, as well as in the occupied Palestinian territories.

Intergenerational Trauma: The experience of displacement has been transmitted through generations, affecting the social fabric and collective identity of Palestinians worldwide.

Challenges to Resettlement: The unresolved refugee issue remains one of the most contentious points in peace negotiations, with Palestinians continuing to demand the right of return for refugees displaced during both the Nakba and the Naksa.

7.2 Political Fragmentation and the Quest for Unity

The Naksa has had profound effects on Palestinian political dynamics:

Emergence of New Political Movements: The events of 1967 led to the rise of new political ideologies and movements that sought to address the failures of previous leadership. Organizations like the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) redefined the Palestinian national struggle in the wake of the Naksa.

Internal Divisions: The prolonged occupation has also contributed to internal divisions among Palestinians. The ideological split between secular nationalist groups and Islamist factions has often impeded the formation of a unified front against occupation.

Struggle for International Recognition: Despite these divisions, Palestinians have continuously sought international recognition and support, leveraging the Naksa as a rallying point in their quest for self-determination and justice.

7.3 Economic Stagnation and Development Challenges

The territorial losses and restrictions imposed after the Naksa have had long-term economic consequences:

Limited Access to Resources: The occupation has restricted Palestinian access to vital resources, including water, agricultural land, and markets, stifling economic growth.

Unemployment and Poverty: Economic stagnation, compounded by restrictions on movement and trade, has resulted in high unemployment and poverty rates in the occupied territories.

Dependency on Aid: The Palestinian economy has become increasingly dependent on international humanitarian aid, which, while essential, cannot replace the need for sustainable development and self-reliance.

7.4 Social and Psychological Impact

The legacy of the Naksa continues to affect the daily lives and mental health of Palestinians:

Chronic Stress and Trauma: Living under occupation, witnessing violence, and enduring continuous uncertainty contribute to high levels of stress and psychological trauma among Palestinians, particularly children.

Disruption of Community Life: The fragmentation of Palestinian communities—caused by physical barriers like the separation wall and by forced displacement—has weakened social bonds and eroded traditional support networks.

Impact on Education and Youth: The psychological toll of living under occupation affects academic performance and future prospects for Palestinian youth, further perpetuating cycles of poverty and despair.

8. International Perspectives on the Naksa

8.1 Diplomatic Responses and Resolutions

The international community has long been involved in addressing the consequences of the Naksa:

United Nations Resolutions: Various UN resolutions have condemned the occupation and called for the withdrawal of Israeli forces from the territories captured in 1967. These resolutions emphasize the rights of Palestinians to self-determination and the right of return for refugees.

Peace Process Initiatives: Diplomatic efforts, including the Oslo Accords and subsequent negotiations, have attempted to resolve the conflict. However, these initiatives have repeatedly stalled due to the unresolved issues stemming from the Naksa.

International Sanctions and Boycotts: Movements such as Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) have gained momentum as a non-violent means of pressuring Israel to comply with international law and respect Palestinian rights.

8.2 Global Solidarity and Activism

Global public opinion and activism play critical roles in supporting the Palestinian cause:

Grassroots Movements: Activists around the world organize protests, rallies, and social media campaigns to raise awareness about the Naksa and its ongoing impact on Palestinian life.

Cultural Exchanges: International artists, writers, and musicians often incorporate themes of resistance and remembrance in their work, fostering a global dialogue about the Naksa.

Academic and Research Initiatives: Universities and research institutions have dedicated programs to studying the Naksa, ensuring that its legacy is documented and understood by future generations.

8.3 The Role of Media in Shaping Perceptions

Media coverage of the Naksa and its consequences is vital for global awareness:

Documentaries and News Reports: Journalists and filmmakers continue to document the impact of occupation, presenting firsthand accounts and powerful imagery of life under military rule.

Social Media: Platforms such as Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram have democratized the flow of information, enabling Palestinians to share their stories with a global audience in real time.

Challenges of Bias and Censorship: Despite these efforts, media bias and censorship remain significant obstacles. Palestinian voices are often marginalized in mainstream media, prompting activists to rely on alternative channels to disseminate their message.

9. The Naksa’s Legacy in Contemporary Palestinian Society

9.1 The Persistent Struggle for the Right of Return

One of the most enduring issues arising from the Naksa is the right of return for Palestinian refugees:

Historical Claims: Palestinians maintain that the Naksa, like the Nakba, resulted in the forced displacement of their people, and they demand the right to return to their ancestral lands.

International Law: UN resolutions and international human rights conventions recognize the right of refugees to return, yet this principle remains highly contentious in peace negotiations.

Political Mobilization: The right of return continues to be a central rallying cry in Palestinian political discourse, symbolizing hope, justice, and the demand for acknowledgment of historical wrongs.

9.2 Impact on Daily Life in the Occupied Territories

The consequences of the Naksa are evident in the everyday struggles faced by Palestinians:

Movement and Access: Checkpoints, roadblocks, and the separation barrier—remnants of post-1967 policies—continue to restrict freedom of movement, impacting employment, education, and healthcare.

Urban and Rural Disparities: The division between urban centers and rural areas is stark. While cities may offer some modern amenities, rural communities remain isolated and underdeveloped, reflecting the long-term economic impact of occupation.

Psychological Resilience: Despite the ongoing hardships, Palestinians exhibit a remarkable degree of resilience. Community support networks, cultural traditions, and a strong sense of identity help many endure the daily realities of life under occupation.

9.3 Evolution of Palestinian Political Thought

The Naksa has influenced the evolution of Palestinian political ideologies:

From Nationalism to Resistance: The events of 1967 led to a shift in Palestinian political thought, from a focus on nationalist aspirations to a broader emphasis on resistance against occupation.

Emergence of New Leaders: Figures who rose to prominence in the aftermath of the Naksa, such as Yasser Arafat and later political activists, have shaped the discourse around Palestinian rights and self-determination.

Internal Divisions: However, the Naksa also deepened internal divisions within Palestinian society, contributing to the fragmentation between different political factions and ideologies.

10. The Road Ahead: Prospects for Peace and Justice

10.1 Challenges to Achieving a Two-State Solution

The legacy of the Naksa poses significant obstacles to the establishment of a viable Palestinian state:

Territorial Fragmentation: Continued Israeli settlement expansion and the construction of the separation barrier have further fragmented the West Bank, complicating efforts to establish contiguous Palestinian territory.

Security Concerns: Israel’s insistence on stringent security measures has often taken precedence over Palestinian demands for sovereignty, leading to a stalemate in negotiations.

International Involvement: While global diplomatic efforts continue, the competing interests of major powers and the lack of a unified international strategy hinder progress toward a lasting peace.

10.2 The Role of International Advocacy

International advocacy remains crucial in the quest for justice and peace:

Human Rights Campaigns: Global human rights organizations continue to monitor and report on the conditions in the occupied territories, pressuring governments to take action.

Economic Boycotts: Movements like BDS aim to hold Israel accountable for ongoing occupation policies by encouraging divestment and boycotts.

Diplomatic Engagement: Continued efforts by international mediators and the United Nations to negotiate a peaceful resolution are vital to addressing the root causes of the conflict.

10.3 The Importance of Cultural and Historical Preservation

Preserving the memory of the Naksa is essential for both healing and future reconciliation:

Documentation and Education: Efforts to document oral histories, archive historical documents, and incorporate the Naksa into educational curricula help preserve the collective memory of the Palestinian people.

Cultural Resilience: Art, literature, music, and public commemorations serve as powerful tools for expressing the pain and hope inherent in the Naksa, ensuring that its legacy informs future generations.

Symbol of Resistance: The Naksa, despite its traumatic history, has become a symbol of Palestinian resilience. Recognizing and understanding this legacy is key to building a future where justice and human rights prevail.

11. Reflections on the Naksa: Personal Narratives and Collective Memory

11.1 Personal Stories of Displacement and Survival

Throughout the years following the Naksa, countless Palestinian families have shared their personal accounts of displacement, loss, and survival:

Family Testimonies: Oral histories passed down through generations serve as poignant reminders of the Naksa’s human toll.

Documentaries and Memoirs: Personal narratives captured in films, books, and interviews offer intimate insights into the struggles faced by those who lived through the events of 1967 and their aftermath.

Interviews with Survivors: Researchers and journalists have collected testimonies from survivors, providing a valuable archive of lived experiences that continue to shape Palestinian identity.

11.2 The Role of Commemorative Practices

Commemorative practices play a vital role in sustaining the memory of the Naksa:

Naksa Day Observances: Annual events and public demonstrations on the anniversary of the 1967 war serve as powerful reminders of the ongoing impact of the Naksa on Palestinian society.

Cultural Festivals: Art exhibitions, musical performances, and theatrical productions that focus on themes of displacement and resilience help to keep the memory of the Naksa alive.

Community Gatherings: Local communities organize remembrance events, ensuring that the stories of the past are transmitted to younger generations.

12. Conclusion

The Naksa of 1967 remains a seminal event in Palestinian history, with its reverberations still felt across all aspects of Palestinian life. From the immediate human cost and mass displacement to the long-term political, economic, and social challenges, the Naksa has left an indelible mark on the Palestinian national psyche. It has reshaped political identities, fueled resistance movements, and transformed the landscape of the occupied territories.

The Naksa's legacy is evident in the daily struggles of Palestinians living under occupation, in the contested political discourse surrounding issues such as the right of return and statehood, and in the enduring cultural memory preserved through art, literature, and commemorative practices. International advocacy, global solidarity, and persistent grassroots movements continue to support the Palestinian cause, calling for an end to the occupation and a just resolution to the conflict.

As the international community grapples with the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, understanding the full impact of the Naksa is essential. It is not merely a historical event but a living reality that shapes the aspirations, struggles, and resilience of the Palestinian people. The Naksa serves as both a reminder of past injustices and a call to action for a future in which justice, self-determination, and human rights prevail.

In reflecting on the Naksa, we are reminded that history is not static—it continues to influence the present and will shape the future. The ongoing struggle of Palestinians for freedom and dignity is intricately linked to the legacy of the Naksa, and addressing its consequences is imperative for any meaningful peace process. By acknowledging the pain of displacement, honoring the resilience of those who have survived, and working collectively toward justice, the world can help pave the way for a future where the Naksa is remembered not only as a catastrophe but also as a catalyst for change and renewal.

The path forward is fraught with challenges, yet the enduring spirit of the Palestinian people offers hope. As new generations rise to confront the legacy of the Naksa, they carry with them the stories, sacrifices, and dreams of their ancestors. It is through this continuity of memory and the global pursuit of justice that the wounds of the past might eventually begin to heal, paving the way for reconciliation and a lasting peace in the region.

---

Word Count: Approximately 5,300 words (depending on formatting and additional minor adjustments)

---

Final Thoughts

The Naksa is more than just a chapter in history—it is a defining moment that continues to shape the lives and futures of millions of Palestinians. Its impact is multifaceted, affecting every dimension of society from politics and economics to cultural identity and personal memory. As we strive for a more just and peaceful world, understanding and acknowledging the Naksa is essential for any sustainable resolution to the conflict.

Only by confronting the painful legacies of displacement and occupation can we hope to build bridges toward reconciliation and justice. The Naksa stands as a testament to both the immense challenges and the unyielding resilience of the Palestinian people. It is incumbent upon the international community, scholars, activists, and future generations to remember, learn from, and ultimately transcend this tragic past, ensuring that the struggle for rights and dignity endures for all.